Online Film Critics Society
Home     About OFCS     Member Profiles     Schedule     Forum     Awards     OFCS Blog
    O.F.C.S. Members: Sign In    

O.F.C.S. Members

Movie Overview
Cast
• Catherine Deneuve
• Mathieu Amalric
• Melvil Poupaud
Director
• Arnaud Desplechin
MPAA Rating
Not Rated
Video/DVD Releases
Dec 01, 2009 (DVD)
A Christmas Tale (2008)

REVIEWS
NEWS
INTERVIEWS
OTHER
OFCS Rating: 82% Fresh
Page  
 

"The cast expertly incarnates this family haunted by loss, lovelessness and (literal) bad blood, but the film's unduly protracted duration makes the Vuillards feel like Christmas guests who just will not leave."  Little White Lies  Anton Bitel

3/4
"A gift that keeps on giving"  Film Freak Central  Bill Chambers

"...plays at times like The Royal Tenenbaums without the twee affectations but nearly all the humor."  PopMatters  Chris Barsanti

4.5/5
"a work of intoxicating genius."  Filmcritic.com  Chris Cabin

B+
"There are no martyrs in this anti-sentimental ironic movie that nevertheless percolates with emotion and accepts its quirky characters for all of their flaws."  ColeSmithey.com  Cole Smithey

4.5/5
"If you want to see a Christmas story that's genuinely heartwarming and entertaining without ever slipping into phony sentimentality, you'd better learn to read subtitles."  eFilmCritic.com  Dan Lybarger

2/4
"...ultimately suffers from a middling midsection that's been suffused with pointless digressions and melodramatic crises..."  Reel Film Reviews  David Nusair

A-
"Seems hardly like cheerful holiday fare but nevertheless goes down as richly as plum pudding."  Ozus' World Movie Reviews  Dennis Schwartz

"'A Christmas Tale' finds time for bits that have no reason but strike home as true."  ReelTalk Movie Reviews  Donald J. Levit

3/4
"A Christmas Tale is beautifully acted by all. The bigger dramatic moments in the film are believable, but the occasional fights and arguments cannot hold a candle to the quieter moments of truth permeating out of the scenes."  DustinPutman.com  Dustin Putman

3/5
"Un drama coral y familiar sobre relaciones disfuncionales, viejos rencores, odios y amores, enfermedad y muerte. Puede resultar tan desconcertante e irritante como sorprendente y humana. Lo innegable es la calidad de su elenco."  Uruguay Total  Enrique Buchichio

3/4
"Arnaud Desplechin doesn't so much direct movies as conduct marathons."  Slant Magazine  Fernando F. Croce

4/5
"A dysfunctional French family learning that `it is never too late to bring love, peace and healing into a divisive and unforgiving household."  Spirituality and Practice  Frederic and Mary Ann Brussat

3/5
"[Director Desplechin] has a knack with actors, and for up-close, liberated filmmaking, but he has little sense of how to fit the pieces together."  The L Magazine  Henry Stewart

3/4
"A Christmas Tale is long but it exerts enough of a pull that the 150 minutes pass rapidly, if not necessarily painlessly."  ReelViews  James Berardinelli

2/4
"an endlessly busy and stylish film with a hollow emotional and spiritual core."  Cinema Writer  Jay Antani

8/10
"Arnaud Desplechin's headfirst dive into the complex relationships within a middle class French family is a messy, captivating, and very much living affair."  Window to the Movies  Jeffrey Chen

76/100
"By frontloading the dramatic meat of the story, the film becomes less about shocking revelations or plot twists than the sometimes comic, sometimes serious dynamics of a family under extreme strain."  MovieMartyr.com  Jeremy Heilman

3.5/5
"The family's vulnerabilities and eccentricities burrow under the skin."  Film-Forward.com  Kent Turner

"This could have been an emotionally wrenching film, but Desplechin keeps the tone light, infusing the drama with humor in the most unexpected places."  Cinematical  Kim Voynar

A
"...like a stocking stuffed by the most inventive and mischievous of gift givers."  Reeling Reviews  Laura Clifford

"Each in succession, the curiosities of A Christmas Tale burst from the surface of the film, almost incapable of containing themselves, their passions, their disappointments, their awkward eruptions of alcoholic rage and familial resentment."  Not Coming to a Theater Near You  Leo Goldsmith

3/4
"Controlled chaos of a family reunion highlighed by likeable but flawed characters"  Movie Habit  Marty Mapes

B+
"A Christmas Tale's expansive stew of physical and psychological illness, death, betrayal, longing, religion, and ritual ultimately proves invigoratingly lush."  Lessons of Darkness  Nick Schager

4/5
"Bustling and chaotic like most big families, this film really captures the outrageous collision of personalities in any gathering of relatives"  Shadows on the Wall  Rich Cline

B
"The characters are so nutty that you never know what they will do next. That fact alone kept me interested."  Laramie Movie Scope  Robert Roten

8/10
"A classic French family drama featuring fine performances by legend Catherine Deneuve and reigning star Mathieu Amalric even if the raging and crying might be a bit much for the Christmas season."  Monsters and Critics  Ron Wilkinson

3/5
"Till life do us part"  JWR  S. James Wegg

"... pulses with human life in all its terrible and beautiful irrationality."  Parallax View  Sean Axmaker

A
"The most emotionally rich and cinematically thrilling film I've seen all year, a film that pulses with human life in all its terrible and beautiful irrationality."  Seattle Post-Intelligencer  Sean Axmaker

6/10
"Yet another dysfunctional-family, holiday-reunion film that's no better, no worse than its bourgeois predecessors - unless you happen to be a Francophile."  SSG Syndicate  Susan Granger

9/10
"A picture of unpleasant people treating each other poorly that comes across as buoyant and frankly joyful at times."  Antagony & Ecstasy  Tim Brayton

"Click here to see review"  Wolf Entertainment Guide  William Wolf
OFCS Rating: 82% Fresh
Page  
 


Reviews database provided by Rotten Tomatoes and the Movie Review Query Engine

powered by ROTTEN TOMATOES
All articles and reviews on this website © the respective authors.
All other content © The Online Film Critics Society (0.10)