Home
About OFCS
Member Profiles
Schedule
Forum
Awards
OFCS Blog
O.F.C.S. Members:
Sign In
O.F.C.S. Members
Movie Overview
Cast
Jonathan Rhys Meyers
Radha Mitchell
Chow Yun-Fat
Director
Roger Spottiswoode
MPAA Rating
R - for some disturbing and violent content
The Children of Huang Shi (2008)
REVIEWS
NEWS
INTERVIEWS
OTHER
(1 - 14) of 14
OFCS Rating: 21% Rotten
Page
1
2.5/5
"
The Children of Huang Shi
is so desperate to be the Asian
Schindler's List
, an example of atrocity draped in abject artistry, that it forgets to lay out the context."
PopMatters
Bill Gibron
D+
"Ah, white people. What can't they do?"
BrianOrndorf.com
Brian Orndorf
1.5/5
"history as drivel, rebellion as Sunday-morning hangover"
Filmcritic.com
Chris Cabin
"With all the stories to be told about the war between Japan and China, it's hard to believe that this one was the most compelling or most in need of telling."
PopMatters
Cynthia Fuchs
1.5/4
"A dull dramatization of -- and ill-fitting testament to -- British journalist George Hogg's experiences in war torn China."
rec.arts.movies.reviews
David N. Butterworth
"Too much flat love interest, too much love triangle, and three stock-character grown-ups are in the end too much baggage for 'The Children of Huang Shi.'"
ReelTalk Movie Reviews
Donald J. Levit
1.5/4
"Like an eager frequent flyer, Western paternalism changes destinations but not its baggage."
Slant Magazine
Fernando F. Croce
C
"High-minded and good-looking, but plodding and emotionally rather shallow."
One Guy's Opinion
Frank Swietek
3/5
"Dares to explore the creativity and the courage that go into compassionate action during wartime deprivation and violence."
Spirituality and Practice
Frederic and Mary Ann Brussat
1.5/4
"An ill-conceived weeper that just won't say die."
Palo Alto Weekly
Jeanne Aufmuth
"A TV movie in disguise."
Cinematical
Nick Schager
4/10
"Nothing in this film is subtle or unexpected, and even the hero's several near-death experiences create no real tension"
Playback:stl
Sarah Boslaugh
B-
"... an affecting portrait and a strong story with a compelling backdrop, and Chinese cinematographer Xiaoding Zhao makes the gorgeous locations look magnificent."
Seattle Post-Intelligencer
Sean Axmaker
"Click here to see review"
Wolf Entertainment Guide
William Wolf
(1 - 14) of 14
OFCS Rating: 21% Rotten
Page
1
Reviews database provided by
Rotten Tomatoes
and the
Movie Review Query Engine
All articles and reviews on this website © the respective authors.
All other content © The Online Film Critics Society (0.06)