Online Film Critics Society
Home     About OFCS     Member Profiles     Schedule     Forum     Awards
    O.F.C.S. Members: Sign In    

O.F.C.S. Members

Movie Overview
Cast
• Christina Ricci
• James McAvoy
• Catherine O'Hara
Director
• Mark Palansky
MPAA Rating
PG - for thematic elements, some innuendo and language
Video/DVD Releases
Jul 15, 2008 (DVD)
Penelope (2008)

REVIEWS
NEWS
INTERVIEWS
OTHER
OFCS Rating: 45% Rotten
Page  
 

2.5/5
"Resembling the kind of tale Aesop might spin after one too many vats of homemade Ouzo, Penelope plods along on a desire to endear. All it really does is infuriate."  PopMatters  Bill Gibron

D
"I suppose Penelope would be pleasurable if the title character looked more like a pig and less like a burn victim."  eFilmCritic.com  Brian Orndorf

B
""Penelope" is a new twist on an old fairy tale template that succeeds for the heartfelt performances of Ricci and James McAvoy."  ColeSmithey.com  Cole Smithey

4/5
"Just downright lovely, a gorgeous fairy tale for children and grown-ups alike."  eFilmCritic.com  David Cornelius

2.5/4
"Maybe I've got some subconscious porcine fetish thing going (or something) but I think Christina Ricci looks kind of cute with a pig's snout where her nose should be..."  rec.arts.movies.reviews  David N. Butterworth

3.5/4
"...one of the most interesting and flat-out entertaining films to play at this year's festival..."  Reel Film Reviews  David Nusair

1.5/4
"With some fine-tuning, Penelope might have been transformed into a winning little fable about accepting and loving oneself. As is, it only serves to remind of what could have been."  TheMovieBoy.com  Dustin Putman

B
"A rather delightful family-friendly fairy tale with a nice message and a fey, whimsical attitude."  EricDSnider.com  Eric D. Snider

B+
"This out-of-nowhere wonder charms from the first frame to the last, and joins Charlie Bartlett on the list of early-2008 films that are both wholesome and intelligent."  Film Blather  Eugene Novikov

B
"May not exactly be the belle of the ball, but this ugly duckling updating is certainly fetching enough to serve as enticing family entertainment."  One Guy's Opinion  Frank Swietek

2/5
"An adult fairy tale that is badly hobbled by its uncreative handling of its theme of finding one's true self."  Spirituality and Practice  Frederic and Mary Ann Brussat

2.5/4
"Much as I would like to give Penelope unreserved praise, I can't stretch my lukewarm approbation that far."  ReelViews  James Berardinelli

10/10
"Click here to read review"  Kinoblog.com  Jaroslav Vishtaljuk

2/4
"Less-than-magical fairytale about girl who must find true love in order to break the family curse that left her with the nose of a pig."  Big Picture Big Sound  Joe Lozito

B-
"Although this "Beauty and the Beast" reversal suffers from some miscues and lapses of logic in television writer Leslie Caveny's script, it largely floats on charming performances from leads Ricci and McAvoy..."  Reeling Reviews  Laura Clifford

"McAvoy is... unaffectedly charming... Ricci is her own kind of quirky-captivating... And the two of them even share a fair bit of romantic chemistry."  Flick Filosopher  MaryAnn Johanson

B
"Like its hero and heroine, this movie is not for everyone, but it will be loved by those who know how to appreciate it."  Beliefnet  Nell Minow

2/4
"Mark Palansky goes for Tim Burton-by-Jean-Pierre Jeunot whimsicality with Penelope, a storybook fable that never overplays its cutesiness but also fails to figure out what it wants to be."  Slant Magazine  Nick Schager

2.5/5
"Okay, so she's got a snout, but it's far from Rocky Dennis or John Merrick levels of grotesque."  Film Threat  Pete Vonder Haar

1/5
"Some viewers may find its self-conscious eccentricities to be somehow charming but if you put this film in a contest against other contemporary fairy tales, it wouldn't come close to winning%u2013not even by a nose."  eFilmCritic.com  Peter Sobczynski

3/5
"Despite an extremely uneven style, this modern-day fairy tale has plenty of charm."  Shadows on the Wall  Rich Cline

1/5
"How can a movie with this premise and this cast be so mercilessly dull and stupid?"  eFilmCritic.com  Rob Gonsalves

C
"You know the outcome right from the start."  Reeling Reviews  Robin Clifford

B
"This fairy tale feels pleasantly down-to-earth."  Seattle Post-Intelligencer  Sean Axmaker

2/4
"the girl's ungainly snout is the only unique feature in this otherwise textbook fantasy."  Charlotte Weekly  Sean O'Connell

"The picture has a hapless, meandering quality that's tolerable at first but ultimately becomes maddening, as if it were a cartoon narrative recounted by a distracted 4-year-old."  Salon.com  Stephanie Zacharek

7/10
"A plucky, whimsical romance as the ugly-duckling fantasy morphs into a satiric take on celebrity culture."  SSG Syndicate  Susan Granger

2/10
"Produced according to a formula for squeezing the maximum amount of cloying charm out of the minimum investment."  Antagony & Ecstasy  Tim Brayton

"Click here to see review"  Wolf Entertainment Guide  William Wolf
OFCS Rating: 45% Rotten
Page  
 


Reviews database provided by Rotten Tomatoes and the Movie Review Query Engine

powered by ROTTEN TOMATOES
All articles and reviews on this website © the respective authors.
All other content © The Online Film Critics Society (0.18)