REVIEWS NEWS INTERVIEWS OTHER

(1 - 50) of 54 OFCS Rating: 61% Fresh Page   12   > Next "The movie's real mistake is to take as its focus the single least unusual aspect of September 11--the fact that the murdered and wounded loved their families and were loved back."   Blogcritics.org   Alan Dale C "There's no questioning the importance of this story, but it is a shame that Stone has chosen to be so manipulative with our emotions."   FromTheBalcony   Bill Clark 3.5/5 "In fact...World Trade Center is one of the few cinematic efforts that wants to accurately recreate the confusion and chaos that derives from unexpected disaster."   DVD Verdict   Bill Gibron 5/10 "This account of the horrors of 9/11 feels counterfeit, compromised, and flat -- sadly, it is an ill-conceived and generally unaffecting tribute. "   Freeze Dried Movies   Brian Juergens A "In a sense, it is blatant, clichéd hero worship, but Stone earns this impassioned interpretation through his care and respect behind the camera for the characters and the gravity of the situation."   FilmJerk.com   Brian Orndorf C- "Oliver Stone has gone against his famous character to make a syrupy and gruelingly flat cinematic ode to two brave policemen (John McLoughlin and William Jimeno)..."   ColeSmithey.com   Cole Smithey "Karnes' announcement is an outsized, quintessentially Stoneian moment, burdened with mythic meaning and, not incidentally, reintroducing the political context the film has so strenuously resisted."   PopMatters   Cynthia Fuchs 4/5 "The images of the smoking towers are already planted in our heads, but the hope and courage that enabled the cops' recovery are not as well-known. Stone deserves credit for leaving the conspiracy theories to others."   eFilmCritic.com   Dan Lybarger 3/5 "World Trade Center is moving, tender, and disappointingly shallow."   eFilmCritic.com   David Cornelius B- "Weighing in on "World Trade Center" is difficult; it's well-crafted, but it's also sluggish and meek."   EDGE Boston   David Foucher 2.5/4 "Strip away its 9/11 backdrop and Oliver Stone's World Trade Center is little more than a primetime domestic potboiler about a couple of NYC cops buried under rubble."   rec.arts.movies.reviews   David N. Butterworth 3/4 "...emotionally resonant and thoroughly compelling..."   Reel Film Reviews   David Nusair "... a thoughtful, sensitive and ultimately despairing film that avoids both nut job proselytizing and sugarcoated sentimentality."   Portland Tribune   Dawn Taylor B "... opts for a discreet, quiet and dignified way to show the tragedy and to take away from it something that was uplifting."   Ozus' World Movie Reviews   Dennis Schwartz 2/4 "World Trade Center comes close to being the self-serving Hollywood production many had feared."   TheMovieBoy.com   Dustin Putman C "It's not too soon for a 9/11 movie, but it IS too soon for one that brings it up for no reason."   EricDSnider.com   Eric D. Snider 1.5/4 "A failure at the most basic levels of cinema and its inability to make me feel ANYthing, when any single still image of that day can induce the fear of God, is inexcusable."   eFilmCritic.com   Erik Childress B+ "The film's sincerity makes it impossible to toss around accusations of hokeyness, either "on paper" or in one's own mind; context is everything, and in this context blunt assertions of heroism and near-sainthood are easy to swallow."   Film Blather   Eugene Novikov 3/4 "Well, World Trade Center delivers the piercing pathos and reminds us once again that Stone can make the transitional move and be both inventive and viably affecting."   Movie Eye   Frank Ochieng C "Well-intentioned but equally disappointing...United 93 is harrowing and authentic; this picture is earnest but old-fashioned, obvious and curiously plodding."   One Guy's Opinion   Frank Swietek 4/5 "Salutes the courage and lovingkindness of those who reached out in the darkness to help others on September 11."   Spirituality and Practice   Frederic and Mary Ann Brussat 3.5/4 "World Trade Center is Stone's most potent motion picture since Platoon, and may be the most accessible across-the-board since Wall Street."   ReelViews   James Berardinelli 2.5/5 "The resulting film plays more like a made-for-TV movie projected on the big screen than the product of one of America’s most dangerous filmmakers tackling a day of infamy."   Q Network Film Desk   James Kendrick 2/4 "Oliver Stone's take on one of history's most notorious and devastating days is white-washed with the sentimental veneer of the Lifetime Channel."   Aufmuth.com   Jeanne Aufmuth 6/10 "The movie means well, and we can appreciate the sentiment; it works on the level of heartbreaking spectacle, but it doesn't add more to our wisdom."   Window to the Movies   Jeffrey Chen 3.5/4 "Perhaps the least likely candidate among American auteurs to make this particular 9/11 movie, Oliver Stone delivers a satisfying portrait of Americans’ ability to weather the storm."   MovieMartyr.com   Jeremy Heilman 3/5 "These are voices that deserve to be heard and that there are filmmakers like Stone willing to hear them is more important than anything that might follow."   FilmFocus   Joe Utichi 4/10 "Literally, everything United 93 wasn't."   Planet Sick-Boy   Jon Popick 2/5 "click to read full review in Greek"   Movies for the Masses   Joseph Proimakis 4.5/5 "They aren't superheroes. They are afraid. It's OK to be afraid - to not be afraid would be stupid or insane. Courage is feeling the fear and acting anyway, and that is what these men did."   Cinerina   Karina Montgomery 2/4 "Stone's talents (and his occasional profundity) lie in juxtaposition and bombast, in a breathless, ragged montage."   House Next Door   Keith Uhlich 3/5 "we need to have these kind of movies come out to remind us what happened on that day"   7M Pictures   Kevin Carr 3/4 "If you hold it up against Stone's masterpieces or United 93, it can't help but feel disappointing. But on its own, it's a gripping and emotional film."   Montreal Film Journal   Kevin N. Laforest B- "There is no Oliver Stone in "World Trade Center" with the exception of an ill-advised appearance by Jesus Christ in lieu of his usual Indian shaman. "   Reeling Reviews   Laura Clifford 2.5/4 "Beautifully acted and thoroughly myopic, the film manages to strip 9/11 of its context and scope, boiling it down to an intimate story of decent, ordinary people dealt a staggeringly bad hand and dealing with it, each according to his or her nature."   TV Guide's Movie Guide   Maitland McDonagh 3/4 "Packs an emotional wallop. Thankfully, it's all earned and justified."   Movie Habit   Marty Mapes 2/4 "For all its noble intent the film brings to celluloid life makes just about every fear anyone had about a Hollywood treatment of the 9/11 tragedy."   Mr. Brown's Movies   Michael Dequina 3.5/4 "I think they ought to just give Maggie Gyllenhaal the Oscar right now. She's that good."   Aisle Seat   Mike McGranaghan B- "There is one scene of true brilliance and shattering impact as a mother waiting for news of her son (Viola Davis) recalls that the last time she saw him she scolded him for missing dinner."   Movie Mom at Yahoo! Movies   Nell Minow 3/4 "Stone slyly sneaks virtuoso moments into his story, bringing a modest elegance to a script that frequently feels creakily old-fashioned."   Slant Magazine   Nick Schager 2/5 "Stone hasn't made a movie for a 2006 audience; he's made one for 2036"   Filmcritic.com   Pete Croatto 2/5 "World Trade Center eventually stops feeling like a remarkable story of survival and more like a Hallmark Network presentation."   Film Threat   Pete Vonder Haar 3/5 "So factual and earnest that it misses the chance to say something meaningful."   Shadows on the Wall   Rich Cline 2/5 "No particular reason to exist other than to garland itself with medals for telling an Uplifting True Story About Good Men."   eFilmCritic.com   Rob Gonsalves D "Who wants to feel good about 9/11? I sure want to feel good about 9/11!"   Flipside Movie Emporium   Rob Vaux B "It manages to find the best in people in the worst of times. You gotta love that."   Laramie Movie Scope   Robert Roten B+ "[Oliver] Stone gives us an old-fashioned suspense story that pays homage to bravery and survival."   Reeling Reviews   Robin Clifford 4/5 "It's plainly evident that all of the filmmakers approached the subject matter with appropriate honor and respect. (In other words, this movie is no Pearl Harbor.)"   DVD Clinic   Scott Weinberg "Even when Stone is clumsy, he at least seems to recognize that he can't possibly re-create the experience of these policemen: The best he can do is put it onstage, reminding us that this happened to someone else and not to us."   Salon.com   Stephanie Zacharek B- "Sometimes this kind of writing can evoke unaffected sincerity; other times, it seems merely trite, perhaps reflecting the inexperience of first-time feature screenwriter Andrea Berloff."   Decent Films Guide   Steven D. Greydanus  (1 - 50) of 54 OFCS Rating: 61% Fresh Page   12   > Next