Online Film Critics Society
Home     About OFCS     Member Profiles     Schedule     Forum     Awards
    O.F.C.S. Members: Sign In    

O.F.C.S. Members

Movie Overview
Cast
• Jennifer Connelly
• Ariel Gade
• Dougray Scott
Director
• Walter Salles
MPAA Rating
PG-13 - For mature thematic material, frightening sequences, disturbing images, and brief language
Dark Water (2005)

REVIEWS
NEWS
INTERVIEWS OTHER
OFCS Rating: 53% Rotten
Page  
 

7/10
"a stylish cut above most of the recent J-horror remakes - but once again it seems that the waters of Asian ghost stories flow purer, deeper and darker at source. "  Movie Gazette  Anton Bitel

"Jennifer Connelly's haunting performance as a woman engulfed in an aura of desperation makes it impossible not to empathize with the character she portrays."  ReelTalk Movie Reviews  Betty Jo Tucker

B+
"Salles has crafted a moody, even gothic, psychological thriller that never fails to hold the viewer's interest."  FromTheBalcony  Bill Clark

5/10
"It's more Kramer vs. Kramer than Jennifer vs. the Dead Kid in the Sink... still, too-familiar territory lacking an original ghost story."  Bloody Disgusting  Brian Juergens

B+
"It's familiar material twisted into interesting directions, and even if it doesn’t always succeed dramatically, the attempt is clear, and I appreciate the film for that alone."  FilmJerk.com  Brian Orndorf

3.5/5
"admirable simplicity with an all-enveloping mood"  Filmcritic.com  Chris Barsanti

"Almost worse than these competing illogics, the film offers what might be the embodiment of logic, a lawyer."  PopMatters  Cynthia Fuchs

4/5
"Smarter, creepier, and better than expected."  eFilmCritic.com  David Cornelius

3.5/4
"...[one of the best] films to hit theaters in a long while...a refreshing change of pace from the mindless fare that generally populates multiplexes during the summer months."  Reel Film Reviews  David Nusair

C+
"About as much fun as riding in a broken-down elevator."  Ozus' World Movie Reviews  Dennis Schwartz

3.5/4
"Dark Water proves that the horrors of the human condition are just as frightening, if not more so, than all things that go drip in the night."  TheMovieBoy.com  Dustin Putman

D
"Would have been... more entertaining as an absurdist comedy about the troubles one woman will go through in order to not live in Queens, the Bronx or (God forbid) Jersey."  FilmJerk.com  Edward Havens

C+
"Japan's chief horror export used to be a giant fire-breathing lizard who smashed cities and destroyed things. Now it's damp girls who crawl around and harass new homeowners."  EricDSnider.com  Eric D. Snider

2/4
"Dark Water is a been-there- done-that- over-again- rince-repeater whose true ghosts are the memory of what its copying."  eFilmCritic.com  Erik Childress

A-
"It's a beautiful, beautiful film, one so expressive that you run out of adjectives to describe it and are reduced to repeating 'beautiful' and 'lovely' over and over."  Film Blather  Eugene Novikov

C
"This 'Water' may be agreeably dark, but it turns out that it's disappointingly shallow, too."  One Guy's Opinion  Frank Swietek

2.5/4
"Dark Water has plenty of creepy moments, but few scares, and it becomes bogged down in setup."  ReelViews  James Berardinelli

"The gore-free Dark Water tries hard to establish a creepy atmosphere, but instead winds up being slow moving with not much happening."  SA Movie & DVD Magazine  James O'Ehley

2/5
"A single mother, a mysterious haunting, urban terror: This well-crafted Japanese horror remake has a too-familiar "Ring" to it."  Netflix  James Rocchi

'2.5/4'
"Conventions aside the film establishes a palpable sense of suspicion and dread and manages to retain it throughout."  Palo Alto Weekly  Jeanne Aufmuth

7/10
"A surprisingly faithful adaptation ... it has an identifiable human component that makes its sense of isolation seem disturbingly real."  Window to the Movies  Jeffrey Chen

5/10
"I found Dark Water slow and gloomy, with a lengthy buildup to a less-than-satisfying conclusion."  DVDTown.com  John J. Puccio

"It's a copy, a good copy, but a copy none the less."  Light Views  John Larsen

"Salles manages to make our flesh crawl from time to time... nothing to make you jump out of your seat, but perhaps enough to scatter a little popcorn"  FilmFreak.be  Jonathan F. Richards

3/4
"Un filme bien hecho, mucho mejor actuado y que, a pesar de ser innecesario, logra firmemente su cometido."  Moviola  Jorge Avila Andrade

2.5/5
"About half-way through the movie, I wanted to stand up and scream, 'Okay, I get it! Jennifer Connelly is a great actor! Can we just get on with the story, please?'"  7M Pictures  Kevin Carr

C-
"It's hard to resist sure-to-be-cliched adjectives like soggy and waterlogged when describing this film."  Reeling Reviews  Laura Clifford

B
"[Connelly] does superior work creating a woman struggling to be a good mother while feeling like she’s falling to pieces."  Reel Times: Reflections on Cinema  Mark Pfeiffer

"[T]he relentless psychological desolation that rumbles ominously throughout is unique, and elevates it above most of the genre."  Flick Filosopher  MaryAnn Johanson

3/4
"Jennifer Connelly gives another wrenching and indelible turn."  Mr. Brown's Movies  Michael Dequina

3/5
"Because it's not a festival of horrors, there's time for viewers to notice how well-made it is."  Goatdog's Movies  Michael W. Phillips, Jr.

3/4
"Dark Water is much more ambitious and classy than the advertising would lead you to believe. It deserves to find an audience of discerning moviegoers."  Aisle Seat  Mike McGranaghan

2/4
"A moldy, third-generation retread of The Ring."  Slant Magazine  Nick Schager

4/5
"Se você valoriza a construção consistente de um clima de melancolia e tensão, dificilmente se decepcionará."  Cinema em Cena  Pablo Villaca

1.5/5
"I think it’s finally time to call a moratorium on American remakes of Japanese horror films."  Film Threat  Pete Vonder Haar

3.5/5
"The strong cast, intriguing visuals and subtle scripting keep things introspective and unsettling, until Hollywood takes over."  Shadows on the Wall  Rich Cline

C-
"Salles' Dark Water abandoned what was an intriguing dramatic narrative and wasted it on what seemed like four climaxes, none of them in service of what came before."  TheFilmJournal.com (Ohio)  Rick Curnutte

D+
"The horror of this mostly horrorless movie consists of the title water gushing from every plumbing orifice available. It may be icky but it sure isn’t scary."  Reeling Reviews  Robin Clifford

4.5/5
"Equal parts quiet, creepy, tragic, and visually gorgeous, Dark Water might be one of the best movies of 2005 that nobody went to see."  DVDTalk.com  Scott Weinberg

B
"Salles tends to explain rather than suggest, but he connects with the anguish and abandonment to give this ghost story an emotionally haunting core."  Seattle Post-Intelligencer  Sean Axmaker

"Like so many recent thrillers of this ilk, many of them in some way exploiting the 'innocence' of childhood -- the dumb and unpleasant Hide and Seek springs to mind -- Dark Water falls apart in the wind-down."  Salon.com  Stephanie Zacharek

8/10
"Creepy, chilling, complex - bottom line: it's a very scary movie."  Modamag.com  Susan Granger

3.5/4
"A mature film about the courage it takes to survive in a mortal world that's dependent on temporary relationships."  Film Freak Central  Walter Chaw

3/4
Read review  Q Network Film Desk  James Kendrick

2.5/4
Read review  MovieMartyr.com  Jeremy Heilman
OFCS Rating: 53% Rotten
Page  
 


Reviews database provided by Rotten Tomatoes and the Movie Review Query Engine

powered by ROTTEN TOMATOES
All articles and reviews on this website © the respective authors.
All other content © The Online Film Critics Society (0.10)