Home
About OFCS
Member Profiles
Schedule
Forum
Awards
O.F.C.S. Members:
Sign In
O.F.C.S. Members
Movie Overview
Cast
Shane Carruth
David Sullivan
Anand Upadbyaya
Director
Shane Carruth
MPAA Rating
PG-13 - brief language
Primer (2004)
REVIEWS
NEWS
INTERVIEWS
OTHER
(1 - 31) of 31
OFCS Rating: 68% Fresh
Page
1
4/5
"Una joya de ritmo y de temática."
Cinenganos
Alex Ramirez
"Even as
Primer
's plot ends up seeming contrived, that is, arguably, the thematic point: stories are always unstable and untrustworthy."
PopMatters
Cynthia Fuchs
88/100
"A discombobulating, thrilling, meticulous and challenging filmmaking exercise."
Cinemania
Dan Jardine
2/4
"...
Primer
remains baffling virtually from start to finish - which is a shame, really, given that this does seem to be a really cool premise for a movie..."
Reel Film Reviews
David Nusair
2.5/4
"May be the most intellectually demanding motion picture of the year. Some will find their mind satiated. Others will leave angry. In one way or another, all will be baffled."
TheMovieBoy.com
Dustin Putman
B-
"We are left with a fascinating, well-played story that dissolves in the end -- a pity, really, since it has so much potential up to that point."
EricDSnider.com
Eric D. Snider
2/4
"Betrays its potential for greatness by sacrificing riveting storytelling for unbelievable obtuseness"
eFilmCritic.com
Erik Childress
B-
"A precocious and imaginative work--though also a fairly impenetrable one."
One Guy's Opinion
Frank Swietek
1/5
"Primer has no respect for genuine mystery but relishes obfuscation as being really cool."
Spirituality and Practice
Frederic and Mary Ann Brussat
2.5/4
"So much of the picture is impenetrable that the intrigue always remains dangling—like a cat chasing a ball of string, it’s always just out of our reach. "
eCinemaCenter.com
Gabe Leibowitz
B+
"There are stumbles in this twisting science fiction tale about the perils of prescience, but even so,
Primer
is one of the most auspicious debuts in recent memory."
Mixed Reviews
Gabriel Shanks
2/4
"It has all the hallmarks of an amateur production: questionable sound and picture quality, crude performances, and dubious editing."
ReelViews
James Berardinelli
4/5
"This sci-fi brain-bender isn't for most, but it's the most rewardingly rewatchable movie since Memento."
Netflix
James Rocchi
1.5/4
"ridiculous, confusing, vaguely noir-ish nonsense"
Perihelion Journal
Jay Antani
9/10
"You can choose to be fascinated (like I was), or just give up all together. Either way, you gotta admit, these guys have guts."
Window to the Movies
Jeffrey Chen
"
Primer
isn’t for everyone, but for those who enjoy a complex, tricky plot, it marks the debut of an exciting new talent."
Pajiba
Jeremy C. Fox
4/5
"Confident and well-woven."
FilmFocus
Joe Utichi
"Extremely fresh and interesting -- a real gem of a first film."
Planet Sick-Boy
Jon Popick
2/5
"I don’t need to be spoon fed, but unlock the kitchen for me, would you? And get a new sound guy."
Cinerina
Karina Montgomery
1.5/4
"
Primer
is perfect Sundance material, its bland, anonymous actors and competent, Sprint-commercial mise-en-scčne masked in the guise of independence."
Slant Magazine
Keith Uhlich
6/10
"Definitely this is a demanding and puzzling film that does a lot with its miniscule budget."
rec.arts.movies.reviews
Mark R. Leeper
3/4
"A smart, clever time-travel game played on audiences and with them"
Movie Habit
Marty Mapes
"This is science fiction for... those who aren’t afraid of entertainment that ruins the curve by being scarily smart..."
Flick Filosopher
MaryAnn Johanson
C-
"Unrelentingly boring."
Lessons of Darkness
Nick Schager
3.5/5
"If he could've made some sense of it in the end, Carruth'd have a masterpiece on his hands."
Shadows on the Wall
Rich Cline
A
"...a wonderfully realized cinematic puzzle...the most artistic and thought-provoking science fiction film in a very long time. "
TheFilmJournal.com (Ohio)
Rick Curnutte
"One of the best science fiction films I have seen, and certainly as one of the genre's best in recent years."
Not Coming to a Theater Near You
Rumsey Taylor
3/4
"While some may find this talky and drably realistic film a bit heavy going ...
Primer
nonetheless hooks you with its crisp storytelling and ingenious premise."
Reel.com
Timothy Knight
1.5/4
"As inert and disinteresting as the base paint after which it's named."
Film Freak Central
Walter Chaw
"Click here to see review"
Wolf Entertainment Guide
William Wolf
3/4
Read review
Big Picture Big Sound
Joe Lozito
(1 - 31) of 31
OFCS Rating: 68% Fresh
Page
1
Reviews database provided by
Rotten Tomatoes
and the
Movie Review Query Engine
All articles and reviews on this website © the respective authors.
All other content © The Online Film Critics Society (0.53)