Online Film Critics Society
Home     About OFCS     Member Profiles     Schedule     Forum     Awards
    O.F.C.S. Members: Sign In    

O.F.C.S. Members

Movie Overview
Cast
• Rory Culkin
• Ryan Kelley
• Scott Mechlowicz
Director
• Jacob Estes
MPAA Rating
R - language, sexual references, teen drug and alcohol use
Mean Creek (2004)

REVIEWS
NEWS
INTERVIEWS OTHER
OFCS Rating: 90% Fresh
Page  
 

7/10
"A mature, significant contribution to the unfornately growing trend of films that address teen violence (unfortunate in that we need the trend at all)."  Freeze Dried Movies  Brian Juergens

"George -- the seeming villain -- is as complicated a character as Sam."  PopMatters  Cynthia Fuchs

6/10
"example of everything that is good in American independent cinema"  Draxblog Movie Reviews  Dragan Antulov

4/4
"A frightening journey into the heart of human darkness and morality. Sure to endure as a watermark of the coming-of-age genre for years to come."  TheMovieBoy.com  Dustin Putman

B
"If this smart, psychologically suspenseful film is any indication, Jacob Estes is a new voice worth listening to."  EricDSnider.com  Eric D. Snider

B+
"Rory Culkin delivers a performance of such incredible force that after a while I simply settled into a constant slack-jawed stare of astonishment."  Film Blather  Eugene Novikov

B+
"A combination of River's Edge and Bully that's gentler but ultimately more compelling than either...told with uncommon authenticity and sensitivity."  One Guy's Opinion  Frank Swietek

4/5
"Mean Creek is an intense and riveting morality play that vividly conveys the anger and violence that can result from machismo posturing."  Spirituality and Practice  Frederic and Mary Ann Brussat

76/100
"Follows a fluid narrative that never feels contrived, and leaves the audience with genuine sympathy for every single child involved."  eCinemaCenter.com  Gabe Leibowitz

3.5/4
"Estes has provided a keenly-honed view of human psychology."  ReelViews  James Berardinelli

3.5/4
"For all its hilarity (and there is a lot), Mean Girls is primarily a fascinatingly adroit dissection of high school culture."  Q Network Film Desk  James Kendrick

4/5
"Story of six kids in crisis may not be anything new, but it is remarkably good."  Netflix  James Rocchi

2.5/4
"The script manages a few compelling characters, but the rest falls into that non-descript Troubled Teenager category."  Slant Magazine  Jay Antani

3.5/4
"The poignant story represents its players’ vulnerabilities with swift and clean lines."  Palo Alto Weekly  Jeanne Aufmuth

"The film gives us an adult’s idea of what kids are like, avoiding the complications and inconsistencies of actual adolescence."  Pajiba  Jeremy C. Fox

7/10
"For a debut, it’s downright startling."  Planet Sick-Boy  Jon Popick

3/5
"Instead of shock, the effect [director] Estes successfully achieves is empathy."  Film-Forward.com  Kent Turner

B
"A remarkable feat...the audience not only becomes part of the film, but becomes young again."  IGN Movies  Larry Carroll

A-
"Estes' amazing ensemble cast may turn out to be the 2004 version of Coppola's "The Outsiders," which featured such 'unknowns' as Tom Cruise, Matt Dillon and Diane Lane. "  Reeling Reviews  Laura Clifford

4/5
"There isn't a one-note character in the mix, and they respond with haunting, subtle performances that feel utterly natural and unaffected."  TV Guide's Movie Guide  Maitland McDonagh

"[P]ainfully raw... pulls no punches, makes no apologies or excuses..."  Flick Filosopher  MaryAnn Johanson

3.5/4
"I’ve actually known my fair share of troubled kids, and this film is as accurate a depiction of them as I’ve ever seen."  Aisle Seat  Mike McGranaghan

B
"After-school-special level dialogue hangs heavily in the air after it is spoken. But the cast is utterly genuine, transcending the limits of the screenplay. "  Movie Mom at Yahoo! Movies  Nell Minow

3.5/5
"An astute examination of youth culture that blows away Hollywood's pathetic attempts to get into the mind of a teen."  Shadows on the Wall  Rich Cline

A-
"“Mean Creek” is what independent film should be."  Reeling Reviews  Robin Clifford

B-
"Directed with a naked naturalism in a rural Oregon setting, it's so earnest it hurts."  Seattle Post-Intelligencer  Sean Axmaker

2.5/4
"A flawed yet promising first film from a writer/director whose ambitions exceed his grasp, at least for now."  Reel.com  Timothy Knight

4/4
"A coming-of-age film that finds poetry in the struggle to evolve even while the rest of the world is falling down."  Film Freak Central  Walter Chaw

7/10
Read review  Movie Gazette  Anton Bitel

Read review  In the Dark  Jonathan F. Richards
OFCS Rating: 90% Fresh
Page  
 


Reviews database provided by Rotten Tomatoes and the Movie Review Query Engine

powered by ROTTEN TOMATOES
All articles and reviews on this website © the respective authors.
All other content © The Online Film Critics Society (0.12)