Online Film Critics Society
Home     About OFCS     Member Profiles     Schedule     Forum     Awards     OFCS Blog
    O.F.C.S. Members: Sign In    

O.F.C.S. Members

Movie Overview
Cast
• Zach Braff
• Natalie Portman
• Ian Holm
Director
• Zach Braff
MPAA Rating
R - language, drug use, and a scene of sexuality
Garden State (2004)

REVIEWS
NEWS
INTERVIEWS OTHER
OFCS Rating: 80% Fresh
Page  
 

4.5/5
"...una perfecta fábula, una agridulce historia de amor, un canto a la madurez como necesidad, al amor como motor y necesidad, y a la definición de lo que somos..."  Cinenganos  Alex Ramirez

A-
"It's the kind of small treasure that drops in theaters once or twice a year."  FromTheBalcony  Bill Clark

"While Garden State likely won't stand up over time beside the films it emulates, it certainly can't be faulted for trying. An impressive debut."  Freeze Dried Movies  Brian Juergens

3/4
"A flawed but funny and heartfelt film that suggests: maybe you can go home again—even if that means coming back to Jersey."  Slant Magazine  Chris Barsanti

C
"Actor Zach Braff (NBC's "Scrubs") makes an impressive if unsatisfying writing and directing debut with a plaintive post-modern drama that relies on unspoken dry wit to entertain its audience (think a cross between "Harold and Maude" and "The Graduate")."  ColeSmithey.com  Cole Smithey

"What is Method Man doing in Garden State?"  PopMatters  Cynthia Fuchs

3.5/4
"A sublime and sophisticated debut from writer/director/star Zack Braff, this year's Lost in Translation with Newark, NJ standing in for Tokyo."  Movie Boeuf  David N. Butterworth

4/4
"...Garden State is one of those rare films that manages to speak to an entire generation - much like The Graduate and Fight Club before it."  Reel Film Reviews  David Nusair

B-
"Braff's concern for both his struggling characters and how people with low self-esteem never give themselves a chance to grow seemed heartfelt."  Ozus' World Movie Reviews  Dennis Schwartz

4/4
"Garden State is a beaming, unforgettable little masterpiece, creatively alive and emotionally intimate at the same time."  DustinPutman.com  Dustin Putman

3/5
"Es una buena primera película (...) El problema tal vez sea su incontrolable acumulación de situaciones..."  Uruguay Total  Enrique Buchichio

B+
"Zach Braff's appeal ... is his ability to underplay the comedy, to appear befuddled and intimidated as madness surrounds him."  EricDSnider.com  Eric D. Snider

4/4
"Belongs on the short list of modern films like Beautiful Girls and Lost In Translation which engulf us in an invisible technique known as storytelling excellence."  eFilmCritic.com  Erik Childress

C
"A simplistic and insincere character piece with elements of smug comedy."  Film Blather  Eugene Novikov

C+
"Has incidental pleasures, but it's no cinematic Eden...a picture with nice moments that never connect into an especially enlightening or compelling whole."  One Guy's Opinion  Frank Swietek

4/5
"A spunky romantic comedy about an enthusiastic young woman who transforms her lover with the good medicine of her personality."  Spirituality and Practice  Frederic and Mary Ann Brussat

2.5/4
"It's a forgettable film featuring a throw-away story with unmemorable characters and unremarkable performances."  ReelViews  James Berardinelli

3.5/4
"an offbeat, genuinely moving dramedy"  Q Network Film Desk  James Kendrick

4/5
"Zach Braff's writing-directing debut demonstrates that he's got real talent backing up his ambitions."  Netflix  James Rocchi

2/4
"the quintessential product by and for uninspired times"  Perihelion Journal  Jay Antani

3/4
"Zack Braff works wonders with his spare narrative and funky ensemble."  Palo Alto Weekly  Jeanne Aufmuth

6/10
"A decent film and an ambitious directorial debut for star Braff, but the movie struck me in just such a way that I was able to see the gears turning and the seams being sewn."  Window to the Movies  Jeffrey Chen

8/10
"...a picture that I personally connected with, and one that is likely to be appreciated by most anyone who is still 'searching' for themselves..."  JoBlo's Movie Emporium  JoBlo

95/100
"Garden State is nothing short of genius, as moving as it is hilarious."  FilmFocus  Joe Utichi

7/10
"...a delightfully quirky look at finding oneself and accepting who and what we are and what life is all about."  DVDTown.com  John J. Puccio

3.5/5
"full review in Greek"  Movies for the Masses  Joseph Proimakis

5/5
"Delightful, unexpected, intimate, dark, and funny. Best value for your dollar!"  Cinerina  Karina Montgomery

B
"Braff shows a keen visual sense and scores directing scenes both comedic and touchingly human"  Reeling Reviews  Laura Clifford

2.5/4
"Deadpan, melancholy, and slightly absurd, like Donnie Darko, or Igby Goes Down"  Movie Habit  Marty Mapes

"Braff takes the mundanity that surrounds Andrew and turns it into something artfully absurd..."  Flick Filosopher  MaryAnn Johanson

3/5
"The film's saving grace, ironically, is that earnestness."  Goatdog's Movies  Michael W. Phillips, Jr.

4/4
"Zach Braff should promptly quit his TV show and devote himself to making movies full-time."  Aisle Seat  Mike McGranaghan

B+
"Braff's control of tone, his mastery of image, and feel for creating moments of moments of great sweetness and insight are the qualities of a great film-maker."  Movie Mom at Yahoo! Movies  Nell Minow

"Boasts a sweet, moody rhythm."  Lessons of Darkness  Nick Schager

4/5
"Se todo jovem ator tivesse uma estréia tão promissora na direção de longas, o Cinema norte-americano estaria bem melhor."  Cinema em Cena  Pablo Villaca

4/5
"It's heart is beautifully expressed through humour, dry wit and honest emotion that never gets sappy at all."  Shadows on the Wall  Rich Cline

A
"[Its] closest cousin is The Graduate, which also discovered beauty in the cognitive disconnect between the things we see and the things we logically expect."  Flipside Movie Emporium  Rob Vaux

A
"This is a terrific debut film by Braff, reminiscent of the classic movie, 'The Graduate.'"  Laramie Movie Scope  Robert Roten

B
"Garden State isn’t a great film but is a solid debut on several levels for its creator [Zach Braff]."  Reeling Reviews  Robin Clifford

5/5
"Garden State is a great movie, full of bizarre wit and winning moments, laden with excellent performances and even a few good-natured morals."  eFilmCritic.com  Scott Weinberg

A-
"I drew traces of Cameron Crowe out of Braff’s gem, from his observant screenplay and witty dialogue to his expert use of gorgeous pop music."  Eclipse Magazine  Sean O'Connell

1.5/4
"A worn rock skipping along a smooth, glassy surface."  Film Freak Central  Walter Chaw

8/10
Read review  Movie Gazette  Anton Bitel

B
Read review  FilmJerk.com  Brian Orndorf

3/4
Read review  Big Picture Big Sound  Joe Lozito

7/10
Read review  Modamag.com  Susan Granger

Read review  Cinema Crazed  Felix Vasquez Jr.
OFCS Rating: 80% Fresh
Page  
 


Reviews database provided by Rotten Tomatoes and the Movie Review Query Engine

powered by ROTTEN TOMATOES
All articles and reviews on this website © the respective authors.
All other content © The Online Film Critics Society (0.20)