|
OFCS Rating: 52% Rotten |
|
2.5/5 | "Pasajera, veraniega y con fórmulas probadas, seguro que generará ingresos, a costa de dejarnos en la espera de una cinta que rinda tributo a Asimov con dignidad." |
| Cinenganos |
| Alex Ramirez |
3/10 | "As I, Robot details how Smith must fight for his survival against an army of white men whom he alone knows are evil, the film might have been called 'I, Hollywood'." |
| Freeze Dried Movies |
| Brian Juergens |
| "Del's repeatedly attacked by bad robots, marked by glowing red lights in their chests and behaviors not a little derivative of the first Terminator at his film's end." |
| PopMatters |
| Cynthia Fuchs |
49/100 | "For those who like their sci-fi to have the depth and breadth of comic books." |
| Cinemania |
| Dan Jardine |
2/5 | "I, Robot is a disappointment not because of what it is, but because of what it could have been." |
| eFilmCritic.com |
| David Cornelius |
B | "Will Smith is darker, sexier in his latest summer blockbuster… but despite an entertaining execution of Isaac Asimov’s robotic visions, it leaves you cold." |
| EDGE Boston |
| David Foucher |
2/4 | "A film so detached from Asimov's vision, it emerges as a destabilized attempt at reworking an already-polished concept." |
| Cinemaphile.org |
| David Keyes |
3/4 | "...what we basically have here is a summer movie disguised as a science fiction movie. On that level, it works." |
| Reel Film Reviews |
| David Nusair |
| "... a solidly entertaining Smith vehicle." |
| Portland Tribune |
| Dawn Taylor |
C | "It's a flimsily sketched psychological sci-fi movie that never feels more than being robotic." |
| Ozus' World Movie Reviews |
| Dennis Schwartz |
3/4 | "Some of the most convincing and lifelike visual effects in movie history. This is a wide-scope sci-fi thriller done right." |
| TheMovieBoy.com |
| Dustin Putman |
C+ | "It's fun, sure, but uninspired. We've seen it all before... Will Smith does his old Will Smith thing again, with only the minimum level of actual entertainment to dress it up." |
| EricDSnider.com |
| Eric D. Snider |
1.5/4 | "More like Dorothy wandering lost through the great land of Oz, only without the heart of A.I., the brains of Minority Report or the courage of Blade Runner." |
| eFilmCritic.com |
| Erik Childress |
B | "The effects work here doesn't break any incredible new ground or shatter any records, and yet this is one of the most visually impressive movies I have ever seen." |
| Film Blather |
| Eugene Novikov |
2.5/4 | "...passable as a vibrating escapist flick in spite of Proya’s sporadically flat direction and the uneven interpretation of Asimov’s wry commentary
" |
| Movie Eye |
| Frank Ochieng |
B | "A visually impressive effort that mixes the pizzazz of an action-oriented popcorn movie with a more humane sensibility than is usually the case." |
| One Guy's Opinion |
| Frank Swietek |
3/5 | "I, Robot is an engrossing sci-fi thriller with Will Smith playing a rebel with a cause in 2035 Chicago where robots are in abundance." |
| Spirituality and Practice |
| Frederic and Mary Ann Brussat |
C | "Despite an admirable effort on the part of its creative team, this new technological thriller is at odds with itself from the very first moments." |
| Mixed Reviews |
| Gabriel Shanks |
3.5/4 | "By adeptly combining action and ideas, it proves that Hollywood can still produce astonishing entertainment." |
| ReelViews |
| James Berardinelli |
2.5/4 | "Proyas succumbs to the inane post-Matrix tendency to pump up action sequences with sudden moments of slow motion gymnastics that are almost laughable" |
| Q Network Film Desk |
| James Kendrick |
1/5 | "Big-budget, big-effects tale of men and machines has a tiny imagination and a robo-crafted soul." |
| Netflix |
| James Rocchi |
2.5/4 | "One can’t help but admire a know-how that permits a generation of walking nuts-and-bolts to move effortlessly amongst men." |
| Palo Alto Weekly |
| Jeanne Aufmuth |
6/10 | "A freshly microwaved mix of Blade Runner and Minority Report topped with a big dollop of cheese." |
| ReelTalk Movie Reviews |
| Jeffrey Chen |
| "Sonny, voiced by Alan Tudyk, is the equal of the other two leads both in his screen presence and the empathy he draws from the audience." |
| Pajiba |
| Jeremy C. Fox |
6/10 | "...I can't say that this movie turned out to be the dark, kick-***, sci-fi classic motion picture for which I was hoping, but it was still a damn good time..." |
| JoBlo's Movie Emporium |
| JoBlo |
70/100 | "Far from perfect, but it's entertaining, well-executed and definately worth a look." |
| FilmFocus |
| Joe Utichi |
7/10 | "Nobody is going to mistake this future noir for Spielberg's Minority Report, but for a light-headed adrenaline rush, it works pretty well." |
| DVDTown.com |
| John J. Puccio |
| "For a film that takes place 31 years in the future, "I, Robot" feels dated. Make that carbon dated." |
| Light Views |
| John Larsen |
4.5/5 | "A fun , surprisingly smart ride that is also true to the spirit of Asimov's more thoughtful and low-key work." |
| Cinerina |
| Karina Montgomery |
3.0/4.0 | "It’s good to know that, in the future, we can still thaw out a cryogenically-preserved Will Smith to save the world every July." |
| MovieCrypt.com |
| Kevin A. Ranson |
3/5 | "It may or may not come as a surprise, but Will Smith is out-acted by the robots." |
| 7M Pictures |
| Kevin Carr |
3/5 | "An unexpectedly engaging futuristic mystery." |
| TV Guide's Movie Guide |
| Maitland McDonagh |
4/10 | "Mixing animation and live action nearly seamlessly, I, ROBOT turns Isaac Asimov's robot world into the backdrop for a prosaic summer action film." |
| rec.arts.movies.reviews |
| Mark R. Leeper |
2/4 | "An overbudgeted, underscripted, lazy piece of work" |
| Movie Habit |
| Marty Mapes |
| "[B]reaks new cinematic ground in the realm of speculative scientific philosophy... for 1953." |
| Flick Filosopher |
| MaryAnn Johanson |
2.5/5 | "Props itself up with allusions to Deep Thoughts but in reality is just a long action movie gussied up in special effects." |
| Goatdog's Movies |
| Michael W. Phillips, Jr. |
3/4 | "The message is old hat by now, but I, Robot is a genuine Will Smith Movie. What more do you need?" |
| Aisle Seat |
| Mike McGranaghan |
B+ | "The smallest effects are as seamless and important to the story as the big ones, from Spooner's examination of 1001 robots standing in formation to the wink of an eye.
" |
| Movie Mom at Yahoo! Movies |
| Nell Minow |
2/4 | "Androids may dream of electric sheep, but I, Robot’s multi-million dollar machines are remnants of summer films gone by." |
| Slant Magazine |
| Nick Schager |
3/5 | "Os resquícios da obra original de Asimov são o bastante para que possamos sair do cinema razoavelmente satisfeitos." |
| Cinema em Cena |
| Pablo Villaca |
3/5 | "While not a classic by any means, is still a mostly entertaining experience." |
| Film Threat |
| Pete Vonder Haar |
| "A real missed opportunity - a potentially groundbreaking film reduced to a mess fit only for the slack-jawed mallrats that it is being aimed..." |
| Critic Doctor |
| Peter Sobczynski |
4.5/5 | "Best of all, this is a story that's actually about something." |
| Shadows on the Wall |
| Rich Cline |
2/5 | "The movie is at least a bit less annoying than director Alex Proyas' previous two genre attempts." |
| eFilmCritic.com |
| Rob Gonsalves |
C+ | "There's no swifter way to ruin 'not bad' than a reminder of something truly great... and for I, Robot, that reminder is never further away than the title." |
| Flipside Movie Emporium |
| Rob Vaux |
B | "Good character development and the great on-screen chemistry between Smith and Bridget Moynahan also give this movie a big boost." |
| Laramie Movie Scope |
| Robert Roten |
2/5 | "I, Robot is a movie destined for fast-forward buttons the world over." |
| eFilmCritic.com |
| Scott Weinberg |
| "Strives to be so many things that it ultimately falls away to nothing, a heap of expensive metal parts." |
| Salon.com |
| Stephanie Zacharek |
8/10 | "Despite its familiar, derivative, yet ironic, story, it's a sleek, stylish, sinister fun-flick with a speculative metaphysical ending that makes you think." |
| Modamag.com |
| Susan Granger |
2.5/4 | "While I, Robot is consistently entertaining and considerably smarter than your average summer action flick, it's never particularly exciting or emotionally compelling." |
| Reel.com |
| Timothy Knight |
|
OFCS Rating: 52% Rotten |
|
