REVIEWS NEWS INTERVIEWS OTHER

(1 - 40) of 40 OFCS Rating: 38% Rotten Page   1   2/5 "Leave it to Hollywood to turn an amazing true story about courage and self-redemption into a shameless action extravaganza. "   Filmcritic.com   Blake French 5/5 "This is grand cowboy fun, a wild adventure with a glorious sense of excitement and wonder."   eFilmCritic.com   David Cornelius C+ "“Hidalgo” is a barely entertaining movie; what it does best is prove that Viggo Mortensen has legs"   EDGE Boston   David Foucher 2/4 "...essentially Seabiscuit minus the cheering crowds"   Cinemaphile.org   David Keyes 2/4 "Bogs itself down with overplotting and a languid pace."   TheMovieBoy.com   Dustin Putman B- "You know exactly where the story's going, and you know exactly what Frank's going to do in any given situation, though I admit he generally does it with panache."   EricDSnider.com   Eric D. Snider 2/4 "If I bought tickets at Arlington Park and made a wager, the last thing I want to see is a jockey leave his mount to go rescue someone’s daughter"   eFilmCritic.com   Erik Childress C "If there's one thing I learned from Hidalgo, it's that Americans are better than Arabs."   Film Blather   Eugene Novikov B- "While the picture is well-meaning and handsomely mounted, many will find it too formulaic, earnest and leisurely to be much more than a barely passable diversion."   One Guy's Opinion   Frank Swietek 3/5 "Hidalgo is an old-fashioned adventure yarn that works well and will appeal to equine lovers. "   Spirituality and Practice   Frederic and Mary Ann Brussat 2.5/4 "A sporadically entertaining adventure movie that is hampered by poor pacing, a badly focused screenplay, and cheesy special effects."   ReelViews   James Berardinelli 2.5/4 "at its most effective when it distills everything down to the love story between a man and his horse"   Q Network Film Desk   James Kendrick 2/4 "Nothing kills my Viggo jones like a bad western set in the Arabian Desert."   Palo Alto Weekly   Jeanne Aufmuth 6/10 "A fun/schmaltzy action adventure Disney flick."   JoBlo's Movie Emporium   JoBlo 5/10 "...why weren't the Disney folks content simply to tell a good story? Could it have been because they knew they didn't have a very good story?"   DVDTown.com   John J. Puccio "You would think that playing loose with the facts would make the filmmaker's job easier, but they use the freedom to stuff the script with unnecessary pit stops."   Light Views   John Larsen 6/10 "Mortensen attempts to channel the Ghost of Clint Eastwood Westerns Past."   Planet Sick-Boy   Jon Popick C "Capitulates to weak dialogue, poor pacing, and a half-hearted performance from mumbler Viggo Mortensen, leaving it to be remembered more for a few scenes than as a total film"   Countingdown.com   Larry Carroll B- ""Lawrence of Arabia" locations, "The Mummy's" sandstorm, a rescue a la "Raiders of the Lost Ark," and a scrappy horse besting bigger thoroughbreds like "Seabiscuit.""   Reeling Reviews   Laura Clifford 2.5/5 "Mortensen's charisma makes Hopkins' 'aw-shucks, ma'am' mannerisms surprisingly palatable, but he's still in constant danger of losing the spotlight to the personable Hidalgo."   TV Guide's Movie Guide   Maitland McDonagh 5/10 "It could have been a good adventure story. Disney should have stuck to Hopkins's story whether it was true or not."   rec.arts.movies.reviews   Mark R. Leeper "[A]s grand as old Hollywood and as fun and as breathtaking and as touching as anything you’ll see at the movies today..."   Flick Filosopher   MaryAnn Johanson 2.5/4 "I know Seabiscuit. Seabiscuit was a friend of mine. Hidalgo is no Seabiscuit."   Aisle Seat   Mike McGranaghan B "There is a lot for the eyes, but not enough for the heart."   Movie Mom at Yahoo! Movies   Nell Minow 2/4 "It’s The Last Samurai except that proud Arabs substitute for the dignified Japanese, and our rugged hero is given a stout, mixed-blood equine sidekick."   Slant Magazine   Nick Schager "I don’t object to 'Hidalgo' because it may fudge facts...I object to it because they are used in the service of a story that is, frankly, quite boring."   Critic Doctor   Peter Sobczynski 1.5/5 "A big old chunk of horse poop."   Film Threat   Phil Hall 3/5 "A big, beautiful film that's thoroughly enjoyable even if it never tries to be meaningful."   Shadows on the Wall   Rich Cline C "It's hard these days to associate Viggo Mortensen with words like 'adequate,' 'competent,' or 'workmanlike.'"   Flipside Movie Emporium   Rob Vaux B "An enjoyable ride, as long as you don't take it seriously."   Laramie Movie Scope   Robert Roten B- "If you are in the mood for an old-fashioned adventure in exotic locales with magnificent equines and lots of familiar action, then this may be the movie for you."   Reeling Reviews   Robin Clifford 3/5 "Dances with Seabiscuit of Arabia...of the Rings"   eFilmCritic.com   Scott Weinberg C "Why am I so surprised that a movie about a grueling endurance race takes so long to reach its own finish line?"   Eclipse Magazine   Sean O'Connell C+ "Fitfully entertaining hokum as long as it isn't taken too seriously… Remarkably, Disney doesn't whitewash the more politically incorrect elements of Hopkins' tale."   Decent Films Guide   Steven D. Greydanus 2.5/4 "Although Hidalgo is frequently exciting and has been handsomely produced on a grand scale, you can't help but wonder what either Spielberg or Cameron could have done with this material."   Reel.com   Timothy Knight 1.5/4 "A facile tall tale of race and a race made by Disney in decline."   Film Freak Central   Walter Chaw 1.5/4 "The film's most harrowing scenes are predictable and utterly unoriginal."   Oscar Guy   Wesley Lovell C Read review   FilmJerk.com   Brian Orndorf 8/10 Read review   www.susangranger.com   Susan Granger Read review   PopMatters   Cynthia Fuchs  (1 - 40) of 40 OFCS Rating: 38% Rotten Page   1