Online Film Critics Society
Home     About OFCS     Member Profiles     Schedule     Forum     Awards
    O.F.C.S. Members: Sign In    

O.F.C.S. Members

Movie Overview
Cast
• Scarlett Johansson
• Colin Firth
• Tom Wilkinson
Director
• Peter Webber
MPAA Rating
PG-13 - some sexual content
Girl with a Pearl Earring (2003)

REVIEWS
NEWS
INTERVIEWS OTHER
OFCS Rating: 70% Fresh
Page  
 

4/5
"La cinematografía de Eduardo Serra logra que la luz sea un personaje más, uno de importancia más allá de la historia."  Cinenganos  Alex Ramirez

"Based on the novel by Tracy Chevalier, 'Girl with a Pearl Earring' may not be a true story, but it emerges as true cinematic art."  ReelTalk Movie Reviews  Betty Jo Tucker

2/4
"Girl with a Pearl Earring tries too hard to be arthouse and not hard enough to qualify its tenuous connection to art"  Film Freak Central  Bill Chambers

"Girl with a pearl earring (...) is a movie of few words and beautiful pictures, and the story is as understated as the acting."  european-films.net  Boyd van Hoeij

A
"No artist biopic has succeeded as completely in capturing the magical, inexplicable artistic moment. [A commentary including an interview with director Peter Webber]"  AboutFilm.com  Carlo Cavagna

3/5
"Earring makes a play as an intense tale of love gone wrong amidst a period backdrop. Too bad that kind of intensity rarely comes across in a movie rated PG-13."  Filmcritic.com  Christopher Null

2.5/4
"Lavish but unnecessary."  Movie Boeuf  David N. Butterworth

3/4
"Unlike a lot of films set in this time period, Girl with a Pearl Earring manages to entertain throughout..."  Reel Film Reviews  David Nusair

"Director Peter Webber's 1665 Holland is all grimy streets, picturesque canals and plump-faced schoolchildren, opting for atmosphere over character development."  Portland Tribune  Dawn Taylor

B+
"True to the artist's vision."  Ozus' World Movie Reviews  Dennis Schwartz

2/4
"Peter Webber’s gorgeous Girl With a Pearl Earring is a work of lightweight conjecture."  Slant Magazine  Ed Gonzalez

C-
"Dazzles the eye while dulling the senses. It is as gorgeous as a painting, and almost as motionless."  EricDSnider.com  Eric D. Snider

B
"We talk pejoratively of films being soporific, but this one sort of lulls you into a restful complacency."  Film Blather  Eugene Novikov

3.5/4
"Esta no es una cinta sobre el drama de las relaciones humanas sino sobre la belleza de la pintura, el poder de los sentimientos y la intensidad creadora de los artistas."  Doncinema.com  Flavio J. Arosemena

C+
"The picture's elegant look consistently delights the senses, but its lack of substance ultimately leaves the viewer feeling comparatively undernourished."  One Guy's Opinion  Frank Swietek

"Director Peter Webber has created an erotic masterpiece that shimmers with visual beauty and a deep appreciation of the exquisite art of Jan Vermeer."  Spirituality and Practice  Frederic and Mary Ann Brussat

B-
"A languorous, quietly mesmeric romantic drama of artistic (and other pressing) urges. "  Mixed Reviews  Gabriel Shanks

3/4
"Offers sumptuous visuals and compelling drama effectively intermingled in a pleasing, satisfying production."  ReelViews  James Berardinelli

3.5/4
"a slow-moving, but engrossing film that is full of ... sensual photography that spins visual gold out of the most mundane of everyday activities"  Q Network Film Desk  James Kendrick

5/5
"Servant girl Scarlett Johansson discovers the privileges and perils of being painter Vermeer's muse in a tense, thoughtful masterwork."  Netflix  James Rocchi

2.5/5
"Girl gives us a vividly painted world but only patchily drawn characters — in that sense, it gets Vermeer only half right"  Los Angeles Alternative  Jay Antani

8/10
"Like a painting come to life... the whole thing looks exquisite."  Window to the Movies  Jeffrey Chen

70/100
"So passionately realized by Webber and his team, that its clichés are easy to forgive."  MovieMartyr.com  Jeremy Heilman

6/10
"...she successfully conveyed much of her emotion through her eyes, posture and full lips."  JoBlo's Movie Emporium  JoBlo

82/100
"A terrifically realised film, startlingly emotional and wonderfully visceral."  FilmFocus  Joe Utichi

2.5/5
"captures the look and feel of Johannes Vermeer's 17th century masterpieces ... but the plot languishes on the screen about as long as it takes Vermeer's oils to dry."  ToxicUniverse.com  John A. Nesbit

7/10
"This year's version of Rabbit-Proof Fence – a flick with practically zero story made more than worthwhile for the cinematography alone."  Planet Sick-Boy  Jon Popick

3/4
"'Sobrio y fino trabajo fílmico que demuestra un prometedor inicio de carrera de un joven cineasta que puede ofrecer cosas interesantes a futuro. Verdaderamente recomendable'"  Moviola  Jorge Avila Andrade

2.5/5
"A gaffer's wet dream, but I do not think that screenwriter Olivia Hetreed actually read the novel that was to be the basis for her first feature film."  Cinerina  Karina Montgomery

A-
"Webber perfectly captures the life of an elusive artist trapped in the politics of a household run by three generations of women"  Reeling Reviews  Laura Clifford

6/10
"The novel is trimmed down to almost a vignette telling the story of the model for Vermeer's most famous painting. This is art director Christina Schaffer's film."  rec.arts.movies.reviews  Mark R. Leeper

"[D]elicately underplayed..."  Flick Filosopher  MaryAnn Johanson

B
"At the end, after being teased and seduced, we are at last allowed to gaze on the famous portrait itself, more fascinating and complete than any attempt to build upon it. "  Movie Mom at Yahoo! Movies  Nell Minow

4/5
"Por baixo de sua superfície aparentemente plácida, aqueles personagens vivem uma paixão absurdamente intensa. Como o próprio quadro que dá título ao filme."  Cinema em Cena  Pablo Villaca

2/5
"Visually stunning, but the dull storyline is (pardon the expression) as exciting to watch as paint drying."  Film Threat  Phil Hall

C+
"A beautiful film with a story that moves slower than paint dries."  Laramie Movie Scope  Robert Roten

A-
"While “Girl with a Pearl Earring” is a solid first entry for its director it is, foremost, a film of stunning visual treatment."  Reeling Reviews  Robin Clifford

C
"The quietly tense dilemma crawls along, moving as rapidly as a portrait nailed to a wall."  Eclipse Magazine  Sean O'Connell

"Click here to see review"  Wolf Entertainment Guide  William Wolf

8/10
Read review  Modamag.com  Susan Granger

Read review  In the Dark  Jonathan F. Richards

Read review  Shadows on the Wall  Rich Cline
OFCS Rating: 70% Fresh
Page  
 


Reviews database provided by Rotten Tomatoes and the Movie Review Query Engine

powered by ROTTEN TOMATOES
All articles and reviews on this website © the respective authors.
All other content © The Online Film Critics Society (0.12)