Home
About OFCS
Member Profiles
Schedule
Forum
Awards
O.F.C.S. Members:
Sign In
O.F.C.S. Members
Movie Overview
Cast
Paddy Considine
Samantha Morton
Djimon Hounsou
Director
Jim Sheridan
MPAA Rating
R - sexuality and brief language
In America (2003)
REVIEWS
NEWS
INTERVIEWS
OTHER
(1 - 44) of 44
OFCS Rating: 93% Fresh
Page
1
7/10
"Laughter, tears, madness, magic, and E.T. ... moving ..."
Movie Gazette
Anton Bitel
"
In America
gets better after a muddled start."
european-films.net
Boyd van Hoeij
A
"A rock steady beauty of a picture, this is a delightful holiday film season surprise."
FilmJerk.com
Brian Orndorf
B
"An agreeably uplifting movie that doesn't cheat its way (too much) to its life-affirming conclusion."
AboutFilm.com
Carlo Cavagna
"As lovely and inspired as so much of the film remains -- the delicate camcorder images, the girls' perfect performances --
In America
is troubled and limited by against the specter of race in America."
PopMatters
Cynthia Fuchs
3/4
"Move over the Coen, Wachowski, Farrelly, Polish, and Hughes brothers.
In America
belongs to the Bolger sisters."
Movie Boeuf
David N. Butterworth
C+
"Since the film's intentions were good, I guess I'm supposed to overlook all the contrivances and naïveté."
Ozus' World Movie Reviews
Dennis Schwartz
3.5/4
"
In America
is simple and unpretentious but its humanity and message of inclusiveness is evoked with heart-warming profundity."
Slant Magazine
Ed Gonzalez
"In America es, hasta el momento, la película más personal del realizador más importante que ha dado el cine de Irlanda en los últimos 15 años."
Uruguay Total
Enrique Buchichio
B+
"Sheridan's heart and soul are evident in scene after evocative scene."
EricDSnider.com
Eric D. Snider
3/4
"There’s a hokeyness that’s hard to escape yet one that creates an emotional current that in the end is impossible to ignore."
eFilmCritic.com
Erik Childress
A-
"Bewildering at times, sentimental at others, but never treacly, it shows us America filtered through memory and perception, and a troubled family filtered through America."
Film Blather
Eugene Novikov
3/4
"...a winning immigrant story that is rich and eloquently realized. It’s always an advantage when you can tap into your own experiences and express them so beautifully"
Movie Eye
Frank Ochieng
B
"Might not entirely transcend its roots, but it's entrancing enough that you're not likely to notice them overmuch, or be irritated when you do...a very sweet, hopeful tale."
One Guy's Opinion
Frank Swietek
5/5
"A soulful and buoyant portrait of a poverty stricken Irish family's winning battle to move beyond the wrenching, contradictory, and chaotic emotions of grief into a new life."
Spirituality and Practice
Frederic and Mary Ann Brussat
3/4
"A unique and moving look at the so-called 'immigrant experience' that is as much about family dynamics as it is about the struggle to survive in an unfamiliar country."
ReelViews
James Berardinelli
3.5/4
"Sheridan manages to maintain the delicate balance between the gritty realities of the story he’s telling and the almost fairy-tale-like mysticism"
Q Network Film Desk
James Kendrick
5/5
"Jim Sheridan's latest effort is a ghost story, a personal epic, a celebration of family and America -- and one of 2003's best films."
Netflix
James Rocchi
2.5/4
"The inherent warmth is enough to tip the scales in the drama’s favor."
Palo Alto Weekly
Jeanne Aufmuth
10/10
"After watching everything they go through in the movie, I was reduced to a blubbering mass."
Window to the Movies
Jeffrey Chen
8/10
"Sheridan should also be applauded for keeping the film going at a nice pace, sprinkling it with many lighter moments, as well as one of the more suspenseful scenes from any movie last year."
JoBlo's Movie Emporium
JoBlo
9/10
"Storytelling at its best."
Planet Sick-Boy
Jon Popick
3/4
"'Una gratísima sorpresa, una conmovedora historia sobre la vida y un ejemplo de que el cine puede ser tierno de manera inteligente. Una verdadera delicia' "
Moviola
Jorge Avila Andrade
4.5/5
"One cannot help but get emotionally involved with this movie."
Cinerina
Karina Montgomery
"New York is as magical here as was Steven Spielberg's everywhere suburbia in
E.T.: The Extra-Terrestrial
(1982)."
DVDTalk.com
Keith Uhlich
2.25/5
"Two child actors provide the strongest sense of realty in a disjointed tearjerker, where there’s a disconnect between what is said and what is shown."
Film-Forward.com
Kent Turner
4/4
"There’s nothing quite like a movie with characters you fall in love with, characters you actually miss when the lights go up. "
Montreal Film Journal
Kevin N. Laforest
B+
"
In America
is a terrific immigrant saga so well told that its few cliches never feel manipulative. It's got the soul of an Irish poet. "
Reeling Reviews
Laura Clifford
3/4
"
In America
is a movie that believes in magic"
Movie Habit
Marty Mapes
"Keepsake childhood secrets and family tales that grow longer with every retelling: that’s the warmth that envelops even the moments that are stormy or scary..."
Flick Filosopher
MaryAnn Johanson
3.5/4
"Click to read review"
Mr. Brown's Movies
Michael Dequina
4/5
"It is a spiritual film but not a preachy one."
Goatdog's Movies
Michael W. Phillips, Jr.
4/4
"The word that keeps coming to mind is “beautiful.” It’s a beautiful story, beautifully written and directed, beautifully acted, and beautifully realized."
Aisle Seat
Mike McGranaghan
B+
"Exquisitely tender...The story may be predictable, but thankfully it is messy and episodic enough to capture the attention and even the heart."
Movie Mom at Yahoo! Movies
Nell Minow
B+
"Superbly evokes the depression, anxiety, joy, misery, and aggravation of family life."
Lessons of Darkness
Nick Schager
"It isn't a very good film but it does contain moments strong enough to make you forget that fact."
Critic Doctor
Peter Sobczynski
4/5
"For a story about normal, everyday life (and death), this is an extraordinary film, really."
Shadows on the Wall
Rich Cline
A
"Has some of the best acting in it I've seen in any film in 2003."
Laramie Movie Scope
Robert Roten
B+
"a warm family tale that has the heart to become an annual holiday viewing."
Reeling Reviews
Robin Clifford
8/10
"A poignant, heart-warming, timeless tale of faith and hope."
www.susangranger.com
Susan Granger
3/4
"Although the film's episodic structure sometimes relies too much on contrivance to propel the narrative,
In America
's charms ultimately outnumber its flaws."
Reel.com
Timothy Knight
3.5/4
"A limpid, lovely fantasy."
Film Freak Central
Walter Chaw
"Click here to see review"
Wolf Entertainment Guide
William Wolf
Read review
In the Dark
Jonathan F. Richards
(1 - 44) of 44
OFCS Rating: 93% Fresh
Page
1
Reviews database provided by
Rotten Tomatoes
and the
Movie Review Query Engine
All articles and reviews on this website © the respective authors.
All other content © The Online Film Critics Society (0.21)