Online Film Critics Society
Home     About OFCS     Member Profiles     Schedule     Forum     Awards
    O.F.C.S. Members: Sign In    

O.F.C.S. Members

Movie Overview
Cast
• Mercedes Moran
• Carlos Belloso
Director
• Lucrecia Martel
MPAA Rating
R - for some sexual content and brief nudity.
The Holy Girl (2005)

REVIEWS
NEWS
INTERVIEWS
OTHER
OFCS Rating: 64% Fresh
Page  
 

D
"Martel is determined to make an impressionistic film out of miniscule moments, fragmented sounds, and fleeting images—so miniscule, fragmented, and fleeting they never cohere."  AboutFilm.com  Carlo Cavagna

2.5/5
"what should have been a religious experience comes off more like a botched coming-of-age tale with some pungent atmospherics."  Filmcritic.com  Chris Barsanti

A
"Martel's distinctive and fascinatingly innovative style warrants her being considered as an auteur."  Ozus' World Movie Reviews  Dennis Schwartz

"With its themes of good and evil and their mix, 'The Holy Girl' is provocative, if maddeningly paced."  ReelTalk Movie Reviews  Donald J. Levit

3/4
"Martel can't exactly be called a horror film director, but I can't think of another filmmaker currently working in the genre with her knack for tension."  Slant Magazine  Ed Gonzalez

5/5
"Quien haya visto La Ciénaga reconocerá en La Niña Santa su manera de mirar y revelar la naturaleza humana desde la pequeñez y la aparente intrascendencia de momentos banales."  Uruguay Total  Enrique Buchichio

C
"The subtly sinister atmosphere is certainly striking...but the story is so fragmentary and allusive that trying to make much sense of it is rather like grasping at smoke."  One Guy's Opinion  Frank Swietek

4/5
"The Holy Girl explores the difficulties adolescents and older men have in dealing with the most powerful energy source in the world -- their own sexuality. "  Spirituality and Practice  Frederic and Mary Ann Brussat

7/10
"...at once humane, encompassing every shade of gray, and bracingly cold-eyed in its assessment of human endeavor."  All Movie Guide  Josh Ralske

"A slow, uninteresting, uninspired and most of all, uninvolved piece of work"  Monsters At Play  Lawrence P. Raffel

2/5
"In stripping her potentially lurid material of salacious appeal, Martel also makes it murky and oddly arid, a mind-numbing exercise rather than an experience."  TV Guide's Movie Guide  Maitland McDonagh

3.5/5
"Almost dreamlike in its examination of obsession, sexual awakening and redemption."  Shadows on the Wall  Rich Cline

"Click here to see review"  Wolf Entertainment Guide  William Wolf

7/10
Read review  Movie Gazette  Anton Bitel
OFCS Rating: 64% Fresh
Page  
 


Reviews database provided by Rotten Tomatoes and the Movie Review Query Engine

powered by ROTTEN TOMATOES
All articles and reviews on this website © the respective authors.
All other content © The Online Film Critics Society (0.09)